BUFFALO BULLETIN BOARD
Speak your mind...


FEBRUARY 4, 2006

To: yell_superintendent@nps.gov
Subject: Buffalo

I am extremely displeased with you policy concerning the Buffalo. If the population needs to be reduced, why not test the captured 550 animals for brucellosis, slaughter the ones testing positive and send the rest to the various Indian reservations who have been pleading for Buffalos to start their own herds. They are out of the park. They are not dead. They are not domesticated. They are managed. You guys don't come across as killers and careless caretakers.

My big complaint with you this year is that you did not even wait for the count to be taken . You don't know how many Buffalo there are after the winter and yet you are killing them. Are you being careful to not wipe out entire herds? They need gene diversity to thrive and recover from the culls.

Please rethink you handling of the Buffalo population. They should be considered protected wildlife, with planned controlled hunts and free movement to thousand year-old migration grounds. Snowmobile routes have increased the Buffalos time out of the park boarders. Couldn't you maintain tracks inside the park but keep a substantial natural barrier boarding the roads and park boundaries?

Right now to those of us looking in from the outside, you look like bumbling, murdering, desk jockeys. I know enough of how difficult it is to do what is best for a large park from living for years on an island that is 65% national park. It is not easy to do what is best for the park and the people who live around it. No one is every happy with you. However, on this issue, I pray you can do better. There are good alterative to slaughtering theses pieces of our country's soul.

Sincerely, DL Lemm

JANUARY 19, 2006  ~  My Letter to the FWP

Montana Fish, Wildlife & Parks, C/o Bison Quarantine,
P.O. Box 200701, Helena, MT 59620-0701,
 or e-mail BisonQuarantineEA@mt.gov

January 19, 2006

Dear Sir,
I am strongly opposed to the Quarantine of our Yellowstone Buffalo.  I see no need to haze, capture and quarantine young Buffalo, when the Park has already captured 500 Buffalo in the past week.  It would be less stressful on the babies and more economical to test for Brucellosis in those adult Buffalo that have already been captured, and to ship those adults that test negative to other destinations. That would save the millions of dollars that would be spent on the Quarantine Facility. It would also lower the population of the Yellowstone Buffalo without risking the chance of destroying forever, the last pure genetic buffalo in the world. If you continue to slaughter all those Buffalo that exceed the number of 3000 without testing for Brucellosis, you may be destroying many of those who would otherwise test negative. One more thing. How can anyone believe in the eradication of Brucellosis in the Buffalo when there are 120,000 Elk in the Yellowstone ecosystem?  Elk who share the cattle feeding grounds and have already transmitted Brucellosis to the cattle. I am ashamed of the Park Service for their participation in these projects, and also that my tax money is being spent on this senseless hazing, capturing, slaughtering and quarantining of our last wild Buffalo.  As for the Buffalo Hunt, if you wish to Hunt the Buffalo as wildlife then hunt them as such, but allow them to leave the park and have free winter range without being harassed and hazed. Furthermore, make some drastic changes in your Interagency Bison Management Plan, stop classifying the Bison as livestock, and revoke the Department of Livestock's (the DOL) authority.

Do not allow history to repeat itself.  PLEASE stop these policies at once and allow the Buffalo to remain free and wild. Thank you.

Sincerely,
Terrie McClay
Galena, Md.

Montana Buffalo Campaign
December 15, 2005

Update from the Field

Often times we here at the BFC tend to focus on the harder side of life. It is news and unfortunately for all of us involved a fact of daily life. But today I want to tell a different kind of story, one that we don't normally get to tell.

On any given day a group of volunteers will get up, get dressed, eat and head out to stand with our brothers in spirit the buffalo. Some of these days are as hard as any care to remember but then there are the days when we receive a special treasure that reminds us all why we are here. I personally have been lucky enough to see the sun rise over the Rockies, exploding into a kaleidoscope of pink, orange and purple. I have also witnessed herds of elk roaming across the fields, counted not in single number, but instead by tens and even hundreds. I have even seen days when eagles both bald and golden fill the skies with their graceful dance. Above this all, is in a word, the majestic buffalo and among the buffalo there is one that, in my mind, rose above the rest.

We first saw him nearly two weeks ago standing near a hill of golden grass and crisp white show. He stood strong and bold, fully encompassing the spirit of the buffalo but with wisdom normally reserved for elders. When he looked to me, I could see his age. His head hung low, and his horns were warn down to the bone. This by no means meant that he had given up on life, for he was a healthy as a bull half his age.

Grandfather, as some of us began to call him, had the ability to look right through you with no more than a glance. But this was not his way. When Grandfather would look at you it was not to look through you but instead to say, "Come, sit close to me so I may tell you a story of my life and of the Buffalo." He did not use words but instead used subtle movements, feelings, and his spirit to speak. For four days he stayed and told his story. After the fourth day he returned to safety.

Now if I have done my job right you too will be able to close your eyes and see the Grandfather Buffalo. See him as a young calf running and playing in the fields. Later as a strong powerful bull leading his heard from year to year. Then finally as an elder sharing his wisdom to all who will take the time to watch and listen. Let him tell you his story and when he does, keep it golden and pure.

After we win this fight, and we will win, It is my dream to walk into a meadow of gentle green and gold on a warm spring day to lay back and listen to the story of the Buffalo once more. It is then that I know they will tell us all of their story again, though this time they will be not just safe but as always Wild and Free.

To all my relatives,
Kim

THE MONTANA STANDARD  12/24/2005

Richard Merkle 3653 Addision Ave. E Hansen, Idaho

Brucellosis threat pours money into state When the federal Department of Homeland Security designated brucellosis as a select agent that may be developed as a bio-weapon of mass destruction it triggered large sums of federal dollars for Montana in fiscal year 2005:
 
  • $4.3 million for Phase I, II, III Brucellosis buffalo quarantine facilities which equals to $13,110 per buffalo emerging at the end of Phase III as a 4-year-old buffalo, free of brucellosis.
     
  • $441,000 to Montana State University for brucellosis vaccine research.

    $895,000 to the Greater Yellowstone Interagency Brucellosis Committee;
     
  • $660,000 to Montana State Department of Livestock;
     
  • $69,000 to Montana State Department of Fish, Wildlife & Parks;
     
  • $6,900 to Federal Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service, USDA;
     
  • $1.2 million to Yellowstone National Park for inoculating buffalo with RB-51 through bio-pneumatic bullets.

    With this amount of dollars flowing into Montana, it is literally impossible to talk sensibly to the federal, state and research agencies about a practical method to manage brucellosis and delineate brucellosis management areas for this purpose. It has been shown that brucellosis is a manageable disease and there is no reason for the zero tolerance policy.

    We have learned that buffalo will reproduce and occupy their entire habitat and will move to occupy additional habitat if allowed. Population control is necessary because over grazing will deplete the range. The discrete hunting of buffalo on their winter ranges outside the park is an obvious solution to control buffalo numbers.

    What is needed is the acquisition of migration corridors and winter forage areas where licensed public hunters can discretely harvest surplus animals, after they become established on public lands outside Yellowstone Park.

    Joe Gutkoski American Buffalo Foundation 304 N. 18th Ave.

    Bozeman
  • Missoulian   12/23/05

    Hunters want herd to survive, thrive

    Kathleen Stachowski of Lolo, a Buffalo Field Campaign volunteer referred to 12-year-old Wes King's bison hunt as "child's play." I guess I can only speculate on what she was implying, but being with that young man and his family that day I can assure you they all showed nothing less than overwhelming respect and admiration for the game King was in pursuit of, and he most certainly understood the magnitude and seriousness of the opportunity he was blessed with.

    If the BFC would truly accept hunting as a management tool for the Yellowstone bison herd in the future, they really should be embracing this year's hunt instead of belittling the sportsmen (and women, and children) who are participating in it in an attempt to portray us as greedy, bloodthirsty, unethical slobs. Many of the bison hunters - including King and me - are truly passionate about assuring this herd is managed differently in the future than it has been and would like to see some of the same goals realized in years to come as the BFC. Hunters are conservationists too, and although this year's hunt is small, it is a big step in the right direction in the management of this herd.

    One BFC volunteer, an enrolled tribal member from Washington, blessed the young man in a ceremony as he stood over the bison he had shot. I think he surprised his BFC companions when he said this was "A beautiful thing" and this hunt should continue in the future. Volunteers like him are what the BFC needs if it really does want Montana to adapt a different management plan for the Yellowstone herd.

    Daryld Pepprock, Stevensville

    Helena Independent Record  12/06/05

    End bison hunt

    I am writing to express my strong opposition to the resumption of bison hunting in Montana. I find it appalling that your state would allow Yellowstone bison - animals who have virtually no fear of humans - to be hunted.

    The Department of Fish, Wildlife & Parks has also failed to meet its own standards for the management of big game species like bison. You can't even claim that the bison hunt will reduce the risk of brucellosis transmission from bison to cows because the risk is already immeasurable. As you know, there has never been a confirmed case of bison transmitting brucellosis to a cow under natural conditions.

    Montana has failed to heed the lessons of history. To protect Yellowstone's bison and spare your state from another round of national and international ridicule, I implore you to stop the hunt now and work for the development of a more ethical and fair management plan.

    Being a frequent visitor to your beautiful state, I am embarrassed by this latest decision. My time and more importantly, my dollars, will now be spend in more civilized areas of the U.S.

    Larry Myers
    Cleveland, OH

    THE MISSOULIAN          DECEMBER 01, 2005

    Hunt nothing more than slaughter

    Despite Fish, Wildlife and Parks' recent and very obvious courtship of the media in an attempt to beautify the so-called bison “hunt” in Yellowstone National Park, the hunt there is still what it was 15 winters ago: slaughter. A hunt, as hunters themselves insist on characterizing what they do, involves a fair chase: a match between a wild animal that knows to stay out of the way of human beings with guns, is wily enough to avoid such humans, and has the impulse and opportunities to run and hide. As anyone who has seen bison knows, and as we learned painfully during the last Yellowstone bison debacle, none of this applies to Yellowstone's bison.

    As witnesses to this season's first bison killings on Nov. 15 attest, men with guns walk within a few yards of grazing or resting bison, they aim, shoot, a bison falls, it dies as the men haze the living bison who, confused and fearful, crowd the dying bison, and then the bison watch as the men field dress the dead animal. A domestic horse in a field would display more fear of human beings with long sticks, or guns, in hand than the bison display. What could possibly be “sportsman-like” or “fair” about this?

    Issuing 50 permits, rather than 500, requiring that permit holders attend a one-hour safety class, calling the sham hunt “historic” and likening it to what indigenous plains people did on horses or on foot with relatively primitive weapons and out of dire need and with very different cultural and religious perspectives does not change what this hunt really is.

    Please write to or call FWP and the governor's office and ask them to deal courageously with real issues: the loss of bison's traditional winter habitat to cattle grazing just outside Yellowstone's boundaries.

    Deborah Slicer, Missoula


    THE MISSOULIAN          NOVEMBER 30, 2005

    Save roadless areas to save wildlife

    My brother wrote me today from Pennsylvania asking what I thought about the grizzly delisting in Yellowstone and the nearby bison hunting. These subjects have been bantered around my office as well. Full disclosure: I hunt; I eat meat. I realize, whether it's a whitetail from an alfalfa field outside of Great Falls or a wild salmon from the Good Food Store in Missoula, something dies before it's on the plate. The delisting of the grizzly is a coup for wildlife advocates. The bison hunt is a coup for wildlife advocates.

    It is not the delisting of the healthy population of grizzlies or the issuing of 50 tags for the 4,900 head of Yellowstone bison that is the issue but the constant loss of primitive and roadless wildlands that is our greatest concern. These animals, as well as the wolf and elk and so on, need room to roam. They need room to roam without impedance from a trailer court or a 30,000-square-foot trophy house. Our battle, folks, is to save what little precious wild and roadless land is left. That land is mostly public land.

    That land is, for instance, the 10,000 acres (estimate) of publicly owned land near Lolo Peak that some would develop if given the chance. There is no place left in the lower 48 where you can stand and be any farther than 26 miles away from a developed road - a fairly long way for you and me to hike; maybe not so much for a wolf.

    If you want to save the animals it must start with saving the primitive and roadless wildlands. Primitive and roadless wildlands, unlike ski areas and condos, “they ain't making no more of it.”

    Dudley Improta, Missoula


    The Billings Gazette  November 27, 2005

    Montana DOL uses hunters for dirty work

    The first day of the bison hunt in Gardiner was nothing for Montana to be proud of. George Clement Jr.'s bison hunt did not end "only minutes" after it started; it took four shots over a span of 23 minutes and that doesn't qualify as a clean nor quick kill. To see what really happened, watch the video footage shot by the Buffalo Field Campaign: www.buffalofieldcampaign.org.

    For the record, Buffalo Field Campaign is not an "animal rights" organization. We are a wild bison advocacy group composed of all walks. There are hunters and nonhunters among us and we share a common vision: wild and free buffalo roaming unmolested in Montana. We are not in the business of "babysitting" bison as reported by The Gazette. We run field patrols from sunrise to sunset, monitoring bison movements as they enter Montana's killing fields, and we document all actions taken against them.

    Buffalo Field Campaign opposes this hunt because wild bison are not allowed to be in Montana without being subjected to hazing, capture, slaughter, quarantine and shooting. "More tolerance" for wild bison in Montana has only meant that the Department of Livestock (DOL) gets to use hunters to do their dirty work. And remember: bulls cannot transmit brucellosis; wild bison have never done so anyway. What is it that Montana really fears? It's all about the grass and who gets to eat it.

    It's an ethically questionable canned shoot with little challenge involved. The world is watching.

    Stephany J. Seay

    West Yellowstone


    BUFFALO BULLETIN BOARD

    THE BUFFALO FIELD CAMPAIGN

    In the Field with the BUFFALO FIELD CAMPAIGN
    VOICES OF THE MEDIAS UNDERSTANDING BRUCELLOSIS BUFFALO MEDICINE
    MY MEDICINE SHIELD HOME BUFFALO